The short answer
Carrots help night vision if you lack vitamin A, but extra carrots do not give you superhuman night vision.
AssessmentIt's complicated
ConfidenceStrong evidence, but no plain yes or no.
Check important health decisions with a doctor.
What the research says
Carrots supply beta carotene, which the body turns into vitamin A to support eye health (Studies 1, 4).
Low vitamin A causes night blindness, and carrot or vitamin A supplements can fix this issue (Studies 2, 3, 5).
In nightblind women, the mean pupillary threshold improved from -0.71 to -1.42 log cd/m2 (Study 5).
Plasma retinol levels increased from 0.95 to 1.07 micromol/L (Study 5).
Who and what this applies to
Pregnant women with night blindness and older women reporting on their night vision (Studies 5, 6).
Some of this evidence comes from studies of one group only: pregnant women, women only. A result found in one group may not hold for everyone.
Nothing on PubMed matchedName the condition and the treatment, then check again. Edit claim puts your wording back in the box.
Still openIt remains unclear if eating carrots improves night vision in people who already have enough vitamin A.
Rests on 3 studies Read the full breakdown The claim part by part, each study's own conclusion, how big the effect is and who it applies to.
The claim, part by part
-
Eating carrots
Carrots provide beta carotene which is a precursor to vitamin A (Study 1).
-
helps you see in the dark
Low vitamin A causes night blindness, and vitamin A fixes it (Study 1).
What the evidence shows
Carrots provide beta carotene, which your body turns into vitamin A (Study 1). Low vitamin A can cause night blindness (Study 1).
Nightblind pregnant women in a trial received daily doses of carrots or other vitamin A sources for 6 weeks (Study 5). Their dark adaptation improved significantly during this time (Study 5).
A study of older women found that poor night vision was linked to higher beta carotene intake and increased carrot consumption (Study 6). This may mean people with poor night vision ate more carrots hoping to fix it (Study 6).
In pregnant women with night blindness, the mean pupillary threshold improved significantly from -0.71 to -1.42 log cd/m2 (Study 5). Plasma retinol levels also increased significantly from 0.95 to 1.07 micromol/L (Study 5).
The clinical trial studied nightblind pregnant Nepali women assigned to 6 treatment groups for 6 weeks (Study 5). Another observational (people were watched, not assigned) study tested older women using a food frequency questionnaire (Study 6).
What each study concluded
-
Study 5 · Randomized Controlled Trial · 2005
Improvement in dark adaptation did not differ significantly between women who received vitamin A as liver, amaranth leaves, carrots, or retinyl palmitate.
In the authors' own words, from the summary each study was published with.
Why the verdict is what it is
The evidence includes a randomized trial on pregnant women and observational data on older women (Studies 5, 6). The trial shows carrots help people with deficiencies, while observational data shows a mixed link in the general group (Studies 5, 6).
Every sentence written for this breakdown names the studies it rests on. Figures are copied from the abstracts and rounded for reading, never worked out from them. Tap a study number to read it.
The evidence
Based on 7 studies · 3 used for this verdict · 2 strong
- Strong design
- Human study
- Animal or lab
- Opinion or single case
Each book is one study, numbered as in the list. Taller is a stronger kind of study. Solid books, with a silver band and a dot, are the ones this verdict used. Outlined books were read but not used.
7 studies read, 3 used for this verdict. 3 of them background only, never used for this verdict, because they do not test the claim in people: opinion pieces and other papers. 1 of them off topic for this claim. By study design: 2 strong designs, 2 human studies, 2 animal or lab studies, 1 opinion or single case. One bar per study, in the order of the list of studies, taller for a stronger kind of study.
1 pooled analysis · 1 trial · 3 background only · 1 off topic · published 1999 to 2024